Examining the Impact: Did Schools' Pandemic Tech Investments Truly Benefit US Students?
That money went to a wide variety of products and services, but it was not distributed on the basis of merit or equity or evidence.
getty images
In a rush to utilize federal pandemic relief funds, American schools embraced numerous tech companies' offers to provide software and services. These companies claimed that their products would not burden district budgets, as schools could use their allocated federal money.
However, an investigation by the Associated Press found that many of the largest school systems spent millions of dollars on EdTech software and services without concrete evidence of their effectiveness. The lack of reporting requirements further conceals the full extent of spending, raising concerns about the impact on students.
"That money went to a wide variety of products and services, but it was not distributed on the basis of merit or equity or evidence,” said Bart Epstein, founder and former CEO of EdTech Evidence Exchange.
The analysis revealed that schools have little to no evidence that these programs actually helped students. Some softwares were rarely used, casting doubt on their effectiveness.
Tech companies exploited schools' urgent pandemic needs with aggressive sales tactics and unfounded claims, pushing unnecessary software purchases based on marketing and relationships rather than research-backed product effectiveness.
Critics argue that investing in software should not take precedence over addressing pressing issues such as aging buildings and teacher shortages.
The absence of federal oversight and regulation has allowed companies to sell products without providing evidence of their effectiveness. Calls for increased federal regulation and oversight have emerged to address these concerns.
As schools exhaust their pandemic aid, the effectiveness of their tech investments remains uncertain. The lack of evidence, oversight, and regulation in the edtech industry has led to questionable spending practices. Moving forward, it is crucial for schools to prioritize direct instruction, and for the government to implement stricter regulations to ensure that funds are allocated wisely and effectively.
